Both Braintree Labs and Novel Labs Petition for the Federal Circuit En Banc Rehearing

We discussed Braintree Labs v. Novel Labs in a previous post.  In the panel decision, Judge Prost, with Judge Dyk joining, found the term “a patient” in Braintree’s Suprep colon cleanser patent to mean a general class of persons, i.e., a patient population.  Accordingly, the panel vacated and remanded the infringement ruling relying on erroneous…

The Federal Circuit Finds Functionally-Based Genus Claims to Be Invalid for Lack of Written Description

A recent Federal Circuit case shows that broad, functionally-defined genus claims are susceptible to written-description invalidity challenges.  In AbbVie Deutschland GmbH & Co. v. Janssen Biotech, Inc. et al., the Federal Circuit affirmed a jury verdict invalidating a patent, finding that there was substantial evidence to conclude that the claims failed to meet the Patent…